chronic pain care without opioids

Here are the 12 Recommendations the CDC Should Have Made

/ Thomas Cohn, MD

Opioid Abuse recommendationsOpioids and the management of pain have been in the spotlight recently, and rightfully so. Many physicians felt like the recent CDC guidelines for doctors in regards to how they prescribe opioids for chronic pain fell short of addressing the real problem, mainly because CDC Director Tom Frieden placed the blame for the opioid addiction crisis on doctors, calling the problem “doctor driven.” Instead of a sweeping generalization saying that doctors are the problem, physicians feel that the new guidelines don’t address other complex challenges, like medical insurance coverage, legislative policies and clinical realities.

Dr. Lynn R. Webster, former president of the American Academy of Pain Medicine, opted to pen an op-ed that included 12 recommendations the CDC should have made instead of their current guidelines. Rooted in stronger evidence than many of the CDC guidelines, Webster believes these 12 recommendations would better address the problem of opioid addiction, and we tend to agree. You can see Dr. Webster’s entire piece by clicking here, or you can see the 12 recommendations below.

The following are 12 additional recommendations with a stronger evidence base than most of the CDC guidelines, and that would be far more likely to reverse the harm from opioids while not creating more suffering for people in pain. In Utah, a multipronged, state-funded program that included provider education (Pain Med 2011;12:S73-S76) with elements from the eight principles mentioned below was followed by a 28% reduction in the number of unintentional, opioid-related drug overdose deaths from 2007 to 2010, as reported by the Utah Department of Health:

1. Apply the “Eight Principles for Safer Opioid Prescribing” endorsed by the AAPM.

2. Use abuse-deterrent formulations when an extended-release opioid is indicated.

3. Remove the cap on the number of opioid-addicted people who can be treated for addiction with medications such as buprenorphine.

4. Allow nurse practitioners to prescribe medication agonist therapy for opioid addiction.

5. Recommend affordable, perhaps free, access to buprenorphine and methadone therapy in line with public policy that recognizes addiction as a disease.

6. Push U.S. and state legislatures to issue mandates to payors demanding a minimum level of benefits for patients in pain to increase coverage for evidence-based alternatives to opioids.

7. Remove methadone as a preferred opioid for pain from state formularies.

8. Ask that payors require prescribers to demonstrate methadone-specific knowledge before being allowed to prescribe methadone for chronic pain.

9. Encourage the U.S. Congress to increase funding to find safer and more-effective alternatives to opioids for the treatment of acute and chronic pain.

10. Recommend legislation for partial prescription filling for Schedule II controlled substances to reduce the quantity of unused prescription drugs.

11. Implement the National Pain Strategy as a top priority.

12. Consider prescribing naloxone with all extended-release opioid prescriptions.

Alternative Chronic Pain Management Strategies

/ Thomas Cohn, MD

Alternative Chronic Pain TreatmentsChronic pain and prescription opioids are two topics that have been making national headlines over the last few weeks. The CDC announced a new set of recommendations for prescribing opioids and the FDA has required new warnings on opioid medications to ensure labels include more descriptions of the risks, especially for abuse, addiction, and overdosing.

With all the news about the issues with opioids, there has been more interest in alternative strategies toward chronic pain management. In the past, comprehensive chronic pain management programs were a preferred strategy. Over the past ten years, most programs have disappeared due to a lack of insurance coverage. The cornerstone of all these programs is combining conservative use of medications, interventions, and the strong input of physical therapy and behavioral health treatments.

Different Pain Treatment Options

Physical therapy (P.T.) is one of the essential needs of everyone with pain in order to develop a daily exercise program. Further therapy can maximize overall capability and improve the ability to function. The goals of therapy are three-fold. To work on overall strengthening and core muscles, aerobic conditioning, and stretching. Muscle strength allows one to be able to hold up the body and perform activities. Core muscles give the spine the ability to be upright, and most of us do not have good strength in these groups, and with a strong core, spine pain is much better controlled. Pain is often caused by tight muscles, so stretching keeps the muscles at the right length and decreases spasms. All three activities are necessary. It is like a three legged stool; Without doing one of the three, the stool tips over. You need all three bases to be stable.

The next method is a behavioral health intervention, and the goal is to train the brain to help control the interpretation of sensory signals. The brain has incredible power to manage all the signals it receives. Pain sensations are specific sensory signals, and the interpretation of the signals can be consciously modified. Normally the brain would just read these sensory signals as painful. If the brain is receiving many painful sensory signals, a short circuit can occur and the pain can become centrally amplified and intensified. Using techniques taught by psychologists, one can learn to modify the perception of the pain signals and essentially ignore them. Multiple different techniques have been used successfully including progressive relaxation, self-hypnosis, mindfulness, cognitive behavioral therapy and distraction. Again, to be successful with any of these therapies, one has to be interested and willing to put in the time and effort to make the techniques work.

Acute and chronic pain can be very successfully treated and managed with a variety of techniques. Opioid medications in reality are only a very small tool to control these symptoms. Controlling the opioid misuse requires patients to move beyond the want for a simple solution that takes no work. Chronic pain is not well treated with opioids for the long-term. It takes time and effort to control chronic pain, if one does not put in the work, there likely will not be a good solution.